4/13/2015

In which I finally review Insurgent

The usual disclaimers apply. These are my opinions, not endorsed by anyone but me. Also, major SPOILERS of both the book and movie Insurgent.

I thought I might get around to rereading Insurgent before I gave my review, but alas, I have too many writing projects in my head right now. So I will give my review now. Another reason I haven't done this is just because there were so many differences between the book and the movie (and I have been so spoiled with the Hunger Games movies following the plots of the books so well!)

It's been a while since I read it, but I've read it more than once, and I am quite certain that the first half of the book focuses on Marcus (Four's father) wanting to leave Amnity so that he could go back and get important information that Abnegation had been in charge of. And nobody really trusted Marcus, and Four didn't want anything to do with his abusive father. But Tris wants to believe that her parents died for something important, so she goes behind Four's back and helps Marcus get the information. Then there is a pretty moving scene at the end where Tris asks Four to trust her despite the fact that she went behind his back, and he does and broadcasts the message to everybody. Yeah, NONE of that happened in the movie. In fact, I think Marcus was in the movie a whole two minutes.

Instead the movie focuses on this BOX that contains the important message, but only someone who is truly Divergent can open it because they have to pass a simulation for each faction. Um. What? Not to mention, I'll give you one guess who the one is that can open it. Hmmm. It's really tough: Tris.
Some things they did get right, sort of. Caleb betrays Tris and rejoins Erudite. Though they really didn't make a big deal about it. Peter is the one that helps Tris escape, though his motives were kind of off. In the book, Tris has an opportunity to kill Peter but doesn't so Peter feels he owes her. In the movie the chance to kill Peter comes in a simulation, so what we he owe her, really? They got most of the part where Tris and Four are in Candor right, or at least close enough. Erudite does inject everyone so that they can use them in simulations whenever they feel like and Jeanine does make people jump off buildings trying to motivate Tris to turn herself in, and she does turn herself in. But the girl who falls to her death, we don't even know her name until after she's dead. And I thought I didn't feel enough emotion toward them in the book!
There were a couple of things they missed that I think we're pretty significant. For starters, they don't have Tris get injected in Amnity with the calming serum. It's important we know that every faction has its own serum! Also, at the end, the all important message doesn't include the fact that it is Tris's grandmother. And then after the message, all the people everywhere start making their way to the fence. I'm. Only a handful of them leave in Allegient.

Afterward, I couldn't help but wonder how much creative control Veronica Roth has over the films. And then if she doesn't have as much control as Suzanne Collins is that because of the director or the negotiated contract or is someone just convincing Veronica that the changes will improve on the movie?
 Respectful comments welcome.

12/29/2014

The Giver review

I finally saw The Giver over the weekend. I am behind, I know. As always, these are my opinions and nothing more. I mean no offense to any.

First, let me just say that I LOVE this book. I remember it being life changing for me when I read it when I was younger. I include it on all my top ten book lists (top ten books ever, top ten inspirational/ life changing books, etc.)

That being said, the movie was disappointing. The thing is that I can't exactly say why. All the important plot points were there. Jeff Bridges was good as the Giver. Brenton Thwaites was likeable as Jonas. Even the little parts that they added for dramatic effect, were tastefully done. So, why wasn't it as good as the book? Why did it just not feel as powerful? Frankly, I don't know. I don't know if somehow words make the actual book more powerful. I don't know if seeing it versus reading it detracted from the message. I just can't put my finger on it.

I am considering having my husband read it. He watched it with me, and seeing if watching the movie first takes away from the book.

The last word? This isn't one where you should cheat and just see the movie. Read the book. It is actually on sale today on kindle. Buy it. Read it.

11/30/2014

Mockingjay Review

Hello out there! Been a while since I visited my blog. This month has been a bunch of craziness, between our car accident and my countless doctor visits determining that I have to have shoulder surgery. But I was afraid I would forget too much about Mockingjay if I didn't review it soon. I tried to justify seeing it again so that I could better review it, but I just don't see when that will be happening.

Standard warning: Spoilers and more spoilers! My opinions are my opinions, and you don't have to like them or agree with them, but don't make personal attacks on me if that is the case.

I read a lot of reviews on Mockingjay before seeing it myself, especially since it came out in London so much earlier than it came out here. The biggest complaint was that they split it into two parts, and a part of me greatly agrees with this complaint (curse you Harry Potter franchise for starting this!) But then I saw the movie. I honestly don't know what could've been removed, and there was certainly not enough that could be removed to fit enough of the second half in to satisfy. I think the solution should've been showing both films back to back, with an intermission for those of us with small bladders. I even would have paid for both films. This whole waiting until next year is garbage.

As for the actual movie, Jennifer Lawrence was AMAZING. So much of Mockingjay, the book, is internal and what that girl can do with just her expressions makes her deserve an award or two (I will contain my rant over the overlooking of YA films for awards). I liked the "behind the scenes" parts that were added to the movie, things that Katniss wouldn't have seen or known about like Plutarch tells Coin to let Katniss see District 12, to make it personal. And that scene was well done. Katniss even stepped on a skull, thinking at first it was a rock, just like in the book.

Jennifer Lawrence even did a good job singing the Hanging Tree. I mean, I don't think she should make an album any time soon, but if you consider she has no vocal training, and how nervous it made her, that scene turned out great. I liked how they made it lead into a broader scene with the bombing of the dam.

I only had a couple of little disappointments. One was that they took out the scene where Finnick runs out and tries to join them, but is still in his underwear, mostly because Boggs's line there is one of the best in the book, "Don't expect us to be impressed, we just saw Finnick Odair in his underwear."  I was also a little disappointed that Katniss didn't visit the bakery while she was in District 12, to show it to Peeta. I know, it's a little thing, but I would've liked to have seen it. They focused more on Gale in that scene, which was probably a good move because it was about the only way for them to tell that he was the one that saved the people of District 12. The other one is that I feel there was too much foreshadowing of Peeta's state of mind. When I read that he attacked Katniss in the book, I actually had to go back and read it again because it came as such a shock to me. In the movie, you  could tell something was going to happen between Snow's "it's the things that we love most that destroy us." to Gale's confession that the Capitol just let them escape (something Katniss doesn't learn until after Peeta attacks her in the book). My sister who hasn't read the books, wasn't shocked as I thought she would be because of the foreshadowing in the movie. I guess they figured most people have read the books or already knew about that part, I don't know.

Now, I have had my doubts about Josh Hutcherson as Peeta from day 1. If you know me you know that I love Peeta. It is the reason I hated Mockingjay the first time I read it (because nobody should mess with Peeta). And Josh isn't ANYTHING like the way Peeta should look. My biggest concern was how important his ability to act was going to be in Mockingjay. I mean, look what happened with Twilight! Some of these younger actors/actresses need some lessons or experience or something. But he did it. I'm not going to say he deserves an award... yet. I still want to see how he does in part 2, when he has to fight the crazy, but he did a good job of showing his state of mind deteriorating. It was better than I expected (mostly because I was scared he'd blow it).

I may add more thoughts after I see it again. I am also always open to questions and comments.

3/22/2014

Divergent

Another book to movie review for my small group of followers:
My usual disclaimers. These are my opinions. I will not apologize for hating Twilight... etc. etc.

I have read my share of dystopian young adult novels. Anyone who knows me knows that the Hunger Games are my favorite, by far. But the second series that I recommend when people ask me about dystopian, is probably Divergent.

I had some concerns about the movie, number one being that it was produced by Summit, which was the company who brought us the Twilight series. We all know how I feel about that series. My hope was that since being acquired by Lions Gate, Summit would have been improved. Also, as was pointed out to me by a friend, Divergent was better than Twilight to begin with. My second major misgiving was Theo James as Four. I had seen some early Trailers and thought that he looked way too old, especially when paired with Shailene Woodley (who plays Tris). I also don't find him as attractive as other people must.  But much with Josh Hutcherson as Peeta, Theo James grows on you.  I think he did an excellent job of portraying someone who is trying for a hardened exterior while hiding a softer inside. His ability to act helped me overlook the fact that he was not the way that I pictured him.

The movie followed the book quite well, with a couple of exceptions. I think that the PG-13 rating requirement and the time constraints are to blame for most of the alterations to the plot. So, I am willing to overlook most of them. They left out a lot of the fights during training. They left out the girl who didn't make the jump off the train. They didn't show Tris getting stuck on the Ferris Wheel. Those are the ones I will overlook for the reasons above. So, the one that disappointed me that I thought really should have been there was that they did little to develop the side characters. The worst of this was Al. First off, he didn't look anything like I thought he should. One of my friends with me mentioned after that she kept getting Al and Will mixed up. Not good. Then you didn't feel the full on betrayal when he is one of the ones that tries to throw Tris over the edge.

Oh, and I didn't hate Peter like I did in the book. And they changed the ending some, throwing Jeannine in where Four was supposed to be controlling the simulation.

With all of this said, I think I would like to make a statement to movie makers. I think that these books that have a huge fan base could handle longer movies. Speaking for the fans of Divergent and Hunger Games, we would be willing to sit through a three hour movie if it meant you could include more of the plot of our favorite books.

2/12/2014

The Book Thief

Another book to movie review:

Do I have to go through the disclosure again? These are my opinions etc. etc.

I saw the Book Thief on Saturday. First, I LOVE this book. I count it among the top ten books that I have ever read, and I have read a few books. I also consider it among the top ten books that influenced/changed my life (and no, those are not necessarily the same). So, my recommendation? Go read the book. That being said, I know there are people who don't read. I don't understand it, personally, but I know they exist. For those people, go see this movie. It was an excellent and moving movie. I was very saddened that more people didn't see it. I don't think it was well advertised, and it was released "against" too many other popular movies (ie. Catching Fire, Frozen).

Now, for those that have read the book or seen the movie (possible spoilers ahead). I thought it was wonderfully cast. The man who played Hans Hubermann looked exactly how he did in my mind. Lisel and Rudy were also well cast and I liked that they had German accents, even though they were speaking in English. I really only had two regrets with the whole thing. The book is narrated by "Death" as is the movie, but the book Death describes the sky on the day people died and some of the imagery is so beautiful, and I don't think that came across in the movie. The other regret is that they left out the book that Max wrote and illustrated for Lisel, and though they changed it so that he was encouraging her to "write," I think some of the message of the book was lost. The point of Max's story is how powerful words can be, about how Hitler came to power at least in part because of his ability to use words to manipulate and influence people, and since the book is during the time of the Nazi's it is particularly poignant. I also strongly believe in the power of words. They can be beautiful and evoke emotions and images and memories. I love the way they can make you feel and see and taste and smell even though they are really just sounds put together. That is why I read. That is why I write.

So, I liked it a lot, but as almost always the book was better. Maybe in part because it contained words...

1/17/2014

The book to movie review melee

I have seen three book to movie adaptation in the last week. I am going to make some comments. Once again the disclaimer: these are my opinions, take them or leave them. I welcome other people's opinions, about the movies, but keep your opinions about ME to yourself, thanks. Oh, and as always *spoiler alert*. (I put the titles of the movies in a color so that you can just read the ones that interest you, or that you have seen/read).

We will start with Ender's Game.
I saw Ender's Game last Saturday. I meant to see it sooner, but there were just too many other movies on the list to see, and I had heard mixed reviews on it. My thoughts?  It was well cast. I liked Harrison Ford as Graff and Viola Davis was a great Anderson. Even the children were well thought out and cast. Most people's complaint about the movie was that they cut years out of the book. Ender actually started at the Battle School when he was six, and though I see the point in the book, I also see how it may have caused some difficulties in film, especially a movie that has to fit in a two hourish slot. So that part didn't bother me too much. I would have liked to have seen more of the antigravity battles, to show how good Ender's mind was at improvising the fights, but again the time constraint. Overall, I think it was an excellent adaptation, that felt a bit rushed. But hey, I said I would have sat through another hour of Catching Fire, so I am all for making movies longer as long as it feels true to the book. I also heard the complaint that Violet and Peter's political "invasion" was left out of the movie, but to be honest, it wasn't necessary to the plot and would not interest the overall sci-fi public.

The second is The Host.
Why did I see the Host? Honestly, still asking myself the same thing. My daughter decided she likes Care Bears and if you think the 80s versions were painful, try watching the new ones. Any way, so I was desperate for anything else to watch, and it had to be something I could watch on my laptop since she was on the TV, so I was browsing Netflix, and I just started watching The Host...
For starters, I liked the book better than Twilight (yes, sadly I have read both). But the sad part to me is that the plot had some REAL potential, but the book got really slow in the middle, and I kept thinking surely something would happen. Most of the excitement was skipped in the beginning where we could have watched the aliens take over the world, or something with action instead of hanging out underground doing nothing.
When it comes down to it, I actually liked the movie better. They added some action. Some of the lines were still TOTALLY cheesy, and I missed the part where Ian and Wanda fell in love. It was definitely more exciting than the book, but I am still not going to recommend you drop everything and go see it. It wasn't that great. Like I said, there were still some cheesy lines, and the acting left something to be desired.

The third is The Mortal Instruments: City of Bones.
When I started this one, my expectations were pretty low. The book was, ok, but I didn't even finish the series because, once again it got really slow in the middle, and I wasn't blown away by the writing (if I don't recall, some of her metaphors were just plain strange). Also, I know it didn't do that well in the boxoffice, and after seeing the trailers, I didn't bother to go see it in the theaters because it just didn't look that great.
So, my first thought: Lily Collins is a red head like Josh Hutcherson is a blonde, seriously, can't they do something about their eyebrows? And hers were SO thick it was impossible to think her hair wasn't naturally black, at least they could have thinned them out or something. But I digress, the movie was actually pretty good. It made me think about picking up the rest of the series, so that is saying something. I think (it has been a while since I read it) that if followed the plot really well, and though some of the elements of it were different, they were in the book too.

Up next? Hopefully the Book Thief, which if you know me is on my top ten books of all time...

12/10/2013

The Catching Fire Review

Okay, let's get this out of the way first. Disclaimers: This will contain MAJOR SPOILERS of said movie and book, and may also include spoilers of Hunger Games and/or Mockingjay. Also, this is a review. It contains MY evaluations and opinions on the movie. If you don't want my opinions, then frankly, don't read this review. And if you choose to anyway, don't go on to insult me personally in the comments. I know my shortcomings and do not need them listed for me, thank you very much.

This is the BEST book to movie adaptation I have ever seen in my life, way better even than the original Hunger Games. Whenever there are direct quotes from the book in the movie, I consider that a good thing. As always, there were things that were left out, but Catching Fire had so much good stuff in the book, it was bound to happen. Sadly, one of my personal favorite scenes was left out, though they still managed to get in the required line from it. (explanation:) The scene I am referring to is the one after Katniss has to jump out of a tree in order to get over the fence back into District 12. She then returns home to find Peacekeepers waiting for her. She has to make up a story and not act hurt so she doesn't give herself away. I just find the story she makes up and the banter between her and Haymitch and Peeta amusing as they tease her about not listening to where the goat man lives and whatnot. Then, of course Peeta catches on to her being hurt and the Peacekeepers give their warning. Her mother treats her foot and then Peeta helps her up to bed and he says one of the best and most important lines in Catching Fire (even if Katniss doesn't consciously hear it), "Always." And though the movie did not have the scene, they did keep the important line, when she has a nightmare and asks Peeta to stay he says, "sure," but then after she puts her head on his chest he says, "Always." So, they get credit for keeping that in.

Another part I was worried would be left out made the cut, when Peeta cuts into the force field and dies and his line about how his heart seems to be working fine now. Why was I afraid it might not be in the movie? Well, in Hunger Games, I thought the "force fields"/boarders of the arena were too obvious, and I didn't see how they were going to explain how Peeta missed seeing it. They weren't as obvious in Catching Fire. Also, I wasn't exactly sure about the logistics of Sam Clifton (Finnick) giving Josh Hutcherson (Peeta) mouth to mouth and how that would work with filming and ratings and sanitation... I don't know, I just wasn't sure about that. But it is a vital scene. Why? For starters, the emotion. (because this movie wasn't a crazy emotional roller coaster ride!). I bawled when I read this part for the first time. I may have cursed Suzanne Collins even. (You don't mess with Peeta!) But more importantly Katniss's emotion. I think this is when Katniss begins to see that she has feelings for Peeta, and again, it is significant for a line in Mockingjay, when Finnick tells Katniss that he thought it was all an act until that moment and her reaction to it. And the film did a great job of showing Finnick's reaction to it, to lead up to that part in Mockingjay. (BTW, if you are bored or want to be grossed out, go watch any interview of Jennifer Lawrence talking about this scene).

Other than the scene they left out that I love, no real complaints. They changed around some of the stuff with Gale, like why he was whipped and when he kissed Katniss, but it all fit with the story and plot and didn't detract from anything, so I will let it slide. :)

Overall, the emotion in this movie was AMAZING! Jennifer Lawrence can say so much with her expressions (watch her face in the scene where they ride in the elevator with Johanna). Josh Hutcherson can't be ignored either though, he is much more subtle (but I find that Peeta like), so you have to pay attention to him to catch a lot of his. There is one part when they are on the beach and he is showing her the locket and saying nobody needs him (which he pulled off without sounding self-pitying or anything, and I was greatly impressed), and Katniss says, "I do," and kisses him. He gives her this look, that if you catch it sums up everything he feels for her and should just melt her. I love Jenna Malone as Johanna Mason. She has some excellent lines and pulls them all off with perfect Johanna sarcasm. Haymitch even has a great subtle part, after Peeta says Katniss is pregnant, where he gives Peeta this salute that is perfect. The movie is so intense that at times during the arena, I am pretty sure I forgot to breathe, and though I didn't cry like I did when Rue died in the first one, there were tears in my eyes several times, but it is more like there wasn't time to cry before the next emotion than that the emotions weren't as well portrayed.

A part of me is actually really curious, now, to see what Francis Lawrence would have done with the first one since this one was so great and followed the book so well.

I wish Mockingjay was coming out in the Spring!!!! As for Mockingjay, I think the biggest challenges are going to be making it into two parts, and it will definitely put Josh Hutcherson's acting to the test because Peeta is about to get really complicated.

Now go read Divergent, and we will see how they do with that one in March. Already, I think the guy that plays Four is way too old looking.

And you are welcome to leave your thoughts and opinions in the comments.